Trump's $5,000 Vote Checks Face Legal, Funding Doubts

Trump's $5,000 Vote Checks Face Legal, Funding Doubts

Donald Trump, the US President, speaking at a podium, one hand gesturing mid-speech
Donald Trump, the US President, speaking in Dublin on Saturday, predicted Irish unification will happen eventually.Illustration: The Frank

The News

President Donald Trump is doubling down on a promise to send every adult U.S. citizen a $5,000 check if Republicans keep control of the House and Senate in November — a plan that lawyers say he cannot legally order on his own and that the administration has yet to fund.

The Associated Press calculated the payout would cost about $1.23 trillion, based on the number of adult citizens who could be eligible.

Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick says the money will not come from taxpayers. His main example is a visa program for wealthy foreigners that has not launched yet.

The Platinum Card Math

Lutnick told NBC News that more than 100,000 people are on the waiting list for the administration's Trump Platinum Card. "We have a waitlist of more than 100,000 people who want to come," he said. "That's $500 billion."

Under the program, foreign nationals would pay a $15,000 processing fee plus a $5 million contribution to the government in exchange for spending up to 270 days a year in the United States without U.S. tax on their non-U.S. income. The official Trump Card website still lists the Platinum Card as "coming soon," and the government says the $5 million is collected only when an applicant proceeds through the process — so a waiting-list slot is not revenue.

Even if all 100,000 qualified and paid in full, $500 billion covers roughly 41 percent of the estimated cost, according to Newsweek's calculation. Funding the whole thing this way would take about 246,000 people writing $5 million checks.

The comparable Gold Card, launched in December 2025 at $1 million plus a $15,000 fee, offers an expedited path to permanent residency. Lutnick initially said the government sold $1.3 billion "worth" of Gold Cards within days; at a House hearing in April he said just one person had actually been approved, with "hundreds" still in the queue.

The Tariff Math

Vice President JD Vance has suggested tariff revenue could cover the checks, and Trump has repeatedly tied the dividend to his trade policy. The Congressional Budget Office estimated the government had collected about $167 billion in tariff revenue during the current fiscal year at the time Trump announced the plan — several times less than the payout would cost. FactCheck.org calculated it would take more than six years of tariff revenue at the recent pace to cover a single round of $5,000 payments.

Lutnick has also pointed to the government's Intel stake, which gave the Commerce Department up to 433.3 million shares as part of an $8.9 billion investment, plus conditional warrants. National Economic Council Director Kevin Hassett has said the dividend could move through a congressional budget reconciliation package.

Timeline

February 2025

Trump says he is considering returning part of the savings claimed by the Department of Government Efficiency to Americans as a "DOGE dividend." It is never paid.

December 2025

The Gold Card program launches, offering wealthy foreign nationals an expedited green card for a $1 million contribution plus a $15,000 processing fee.

April 2026

At a House hearing, Lutnick says only one Gold Card applicant has been approved, with "hundreds" in the queue, after earlier claiming $1.3 billion in sales within days.

Sept. 10, 2026

Trump unveils the "Trump Dividend" at the Republican midterm convention in Dallas. The same day, Lutnick tells NBC News the checks would not come from taxpayers or add to the deficit, citing the Platinum Card waiting list.

Sept. 11, 2026

Trump reiterates the pledge in a Truth Social post Friday night and hits back at Democrats who call it a bribe for votes.

Sept. 12, 2026

Newsweek publishes an analysis showing the Platinum Card waiting list, even at full value, would cover only about 41 percent of the cost.

Reactions

White House spokesman Davis Ingle told Newsweek that "the doomers and naysayers have consistently doubted President Trump" on promises including the Trump Accounts, drug pricing, the border and taxes on tips, and said Trump "has consistently proven his doubters wrong" and "will keep delivering real results."

Trump told reporters the payment is "a reward for people having to put up for five years and four years of a horrible situation caused by Biden."

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer accused Trump of "trying to bribe the American people for their votes." Rep. Robert Garcia, the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee, called it an "empty promise," citing the tariff and DOGE dividends that never arrived. California Gov. Gavin Newsom said Trump was trying to "buy your vote with $5,000." Rep. Dan Goldman of New York called the pledge "corrupt and blatantly illegal," arguing Congress — not the president alone — must authorize the spending.

Marc Goldwein, senior policy director at the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, told the Associated Press the federal government is already running roughly $2 trillion annual deficits rather than the surplus a "dividend" would normally imply.

Not every Republican is sold. Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas and Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis dissented mildly, prompting a senior White House adviser to tell Politico Playbook that "Ron and Ted — the co-captains of your old high school Math-Lete Team — will nerd out on this while jockeying for 11th place in '28."

In The Atlantic, Jonathan Chait argued the checks are unconstitutional as described and will never be mailed, calling the plan "a facially unconstitutional infringement of Congress's spending authority" and noting that pumping roughly $1.2 trillion into an economy with above-target inflation would likely push prices higher. MeidasTouch, a left-leaning outlet, reported that Community Notes were appended to Trump and Vance posts about the checks and that Trump has fundraised off the promise.

What's Next

Congress would have to authorize the money, and no bill has been passed. Hassett has floated attaching the dividend to a budget reconciliation package, which would require Republican majorities to hold together on a roughly $1.2 trillion line item.

The Platinum Card has not launched. Whether it produces real revenue depends on how many of the 100,000 people on the waiting list actually qualify and pay $5 million — a test the Gold Card, with one approval as of April, has not yet passed.

The administration has not announced an income cutoff, though Vance has suggested wealthy Americans could be excluded. Voters decide the premise itself in the November midterm elections.

More

Trump says the $5,000 would have to be spent inside the United States. He has also said he could distribute the money without congressional approval — a claim critics across the spectrum dispute, since the Constitution gives Congress the spending power.

This is the third cash-back promise of his second term. The DOGE dividend and a promised $2,000 tariff dividend for lower- and middle-income Americans were both floated and neither was implemented.

Poll

Do you expect the $5,000 checks to ever be mailed?

Yes, if Republicans win
0.0%
No — it's a campaign promise
0.0%
Only a smaller version
0.0%
Not sure
0.0%

Russian Missile Destroys Ukrainian Tennis Star's Odesa Home

GOP Governor Candidate Swims From Sinking Plane

Four Killed in Louisiana Stabbing; Manhunt Underway

Colleges Condemn Students Mocking Kirk Assassination Anniversary

Charleston White Arrested Again on Florida Battery Charge

Border Patrol Rescues MS NOW Crew in Desert

Supreme Court Restores Missouri's Old House Map

Alaska Drops Felony Voter Charges Against Samoans

Trespasser Breaches Harris' Malibu Estate; No Arrest

Hegseth Pressed Downed Airmen Into 60 Minutes

Houthis Seize Mokha, Choking Saudi Oil Exports

Altman Rules Out OpenAI IPO This Year

Jury Acquits Lil Durk in Murder-for-Hire Case

Judge: Trump Broke Law Halving FEMA Staff

Maher Calls Democrats' Gaza Genocide Claim a Lie

Blizzard Revives StarCraft, Sends Diablo to Netflix

Trump's Queens Childhood Home Sells for $1.93M

Scientists Find New Virus in Tick Invading US

Britain Bans Settlement Imports; US States Threaten Payback

Prison Fire Kills 7 as Kurds Protest Killing